Webinars & Educational Videos / History of Reading Instruction

History of Reading Instruction: Why Many Students Aren’t Taught How to Read

Emily Hanford traces where balanced literacy and cueing came from, what reading science says about how skilled readers identify words, and why this matters for children with dyslexia.

Welcome video

Run time: about 6 minutes

From iReading Tutor

About This Video

Many parents are surprised to learn that some classrooms teach children to figure out words by looking at pictures, guessing from context, or skipping hard words. This video explains where those habits came from and why reading research says they are not how strong readers read.

It follows the story from early reading programs in New Zealand to popular materials used in American schools, then explains how skilled readers actually store and recognize words, and why phonemic awareness and phonics are essential. This is especially important for children with dyslexia, who need explicit, systematic instruction in how sounds connect to letters.

Key Takeaways

  • Balanced literacy materials trace their roots to the ideas of Marie Clay, a developmental psychologist in New Zealand, who built her thinking into the Reading Recovery program in the 1980s.

  • In the United States, these ideas spread through widely used materials from Fountas and Pinnell and from Lucy Calkins. The video cites an Education Week survey in which 43% of elementary teachers reported using Leveled Literacy Intervention and 16% reported using Units of Study.

  • In these approaches phonics is often presented as just one strategy, alongside using meaning and sentence structure, so children may be taught to guess, use the first letter, or skip a word.

  • According to the research described in the video, skilled readers do not rely on context to identify words. Struggling readers are the ones who tend to guess and skip.

  • Skilled readers store words through orthographic mapping, which depends on phonemic awareness and phonics. That is why explicit phonics instruction matters, especially for children with dyslexia.

Frequently asked questions

Where did balanced literacy and the three-cueing idea come from?

According to the video, the roots go back to New Zealand developmental psychologist Marie Clay, whose ideas, similar to those of Ken Goodman, were built into the Reading Recovery intervention program in the 1980s. In the United States, Irene Fountas and Gay Su Pinnell popularized related approaches such as guided reading and leveled books, and Lucy Calkins’ Units of Study became another widely used set of materials. These programs often present phonics as just one of several cues, alongside meaning and sentence structure, for figuring out a word.

Why is teaching children to guess at words a problem?

The video explains that scientific research shows skilled readers do not use context cues to identify words. Poor readers are the ones who tend to memorize words, use the first letters and context to guess, or skip words they do not know. Skilled readers recognize words immediately and accurately, so teaching strategies that rely on guessing does not build the skill that strong readers actually use.

What is orthographic mapping, and why does it make phonics important?

Orthographic mapping is the process the brain uses to store printed words in long-term memory. It happens in the background when a reader links the letters in a word to its sounds and meaning. It is not the same as memorizing words. It requires phonemic awareness, which is awareness of the speech sounds in words, and phonics, which is knowing how those sounds are represented by letters. Once a word is mapped, the reader recognizes it instantly without sounding it out.

Is your child guessing at words?

iReading Tutor provides explicit, systematic, structured literacy instruction. Book a free consultation, call or text 561-418-6856, or email [email protected].

Watch more on our YouTube channel or browse all Webinars & Educational Videos.

© 2026 iReading TUTOR. All rights reserved. Specialized Literacy Support. Powered by Fluxigo.